Why Managers Tolerate Poor Performance (and What to do instead)
with
Why So Many Managers Tolerate Poor Performance (and What to Do Instead)
It’s a common scenario in workplaces everywhere: a manager repeatedly overlooks or excuses poor performance from a team member, even when it starts to affect team morale, productivity, and overall performance. But why does this happen, and why do so many managers struggle to address underperformance directly?
The reasons often come down to a combination of psychological discomfort, avoidance behavior, and even biological responses in the brain that make conflict management challenging. Let’s explore why managers sometimes tolerate poor performance, using real-world case studies, and look at how neuroscience and management research can help us understand and overcome this tendency.
Understanding Why Managers Avoid Addressing Poor Performance
Tolerating poor performance often boils down to discomfort with conflict and an aversion to difficult conversations. Studies on conflict-avoidance behavior suggest that many managers lack confidence in giving corrective feedback. Managers may fear damaging team relationships, hurting morale, or triggering defensive responses from employees.
Neuroscience Explanation: The brain’s “fight-or-flight” response activates in situations perceived as threats, even social ones. Conflict-heavy interactions, like addressing poor performance, can activate the amygdala—the part of the brain responsible for fear and stress responses. In the face of these uncomfortable emotions, many managers default to avoidance, rationalising that “things will get better” or hoping that performance issues will resolve themselves over time.
Cognitive Biases Reinforcing Avoidance
Several cognitive biases can compound this response, encouraging managers to rationalize or excuse poor performance instead of addressing it directly:
a. The Ostrich Effect
The Ostrich Effect refers to our tendency to avoid unpleasant information or situations in the hope that they’ll disappear on their own. Neuroscientists suggest that the amygdala plays a role here by amplifying the negative emotions associated with confronting uncomfortable realities, nudging people to ignore them. In managerial contexts, the Ostrich Effect might cause managers to downplay or disregard performance issues, delaying necessary actions due to the perceived discomfort of confrontation.
b. The Status Quo Bias
The Status Quo Bias is our preference for things to stay as they are, even if the current state is less than ideal. Studies suggest that this bias activates the brain’s reward circuitry, specifically the nucleus accumbens, which reinforces the preference for stability. In a leadership context, managers influenced by this bias may resist addressing performance issues because maintaining the status quo is cognitively and emotionally “easier” than making a change that could disrupt team dynamics.
c. Cognitive Dissonance
Dissonance theory, developed by Leon Festinger, suggests that holding conflicting beliefs creates psychological discomfort. In managing poor performance, cognitive dissonance might arise if a manager believes in the importance of high standards yet avoids addressing underperformance. Neuroscience studies show that the brain tries to “reduce” this discomfort by altering one’s beliefs or actions, such as rationalising poor performance as temporary or situational, rather than directly confronting it.
Avoidance as a Habit Loop in the Brain
When managers repeatedly avoid addressing poor performance, this avoidance can develop into a habit loop—a concept explained in Charles Duhigg’s book The Power of Habit. Habit loops consist of three components: the cue (trigger), the routine (behavior), and the reward (outcome). For example:
- Cue: The manager observes or is reminded of an employee’s poor performance.
- Routine: Instead of addressing it, they choose to ignore it or rationalise it.
- Reward: They experience temporary relief from the stress and discomfort associated with confrontation.
Each time this loop is repeated, the brain reinforces avoidance as the preferred behavior. The neural pathways associated with avoidance behavior strengthen over time, making it increasingly likely that the manager will continue to avoid similar conversations in the future. This reinforcement can lead to a habit loop that becomes challenging to break without deliberate intervention.
Empathy and Compassion Fatigue
Empathy is a powerful emotion regulated by the brain’s mirror neuron system, which allows us to feel and understand the emotions of others. Managers who are highly empathetic or fear the consequences of a confrontational discussion may be more likely to avoid addressing poor performance because they are concerned about causing distress to the employee.
Compassion fatigue can also play a role, particularly for managers in caregiving or high-stress roles. Studies show that chronic empathy and emotional investment can deplete one’s emotional reserves, leading to a reluctance to enforce boundaries or set high expectations. In the brain, compassion fatigue is associated with reduced activity in regions like the anterior insula, responsible for emotional regulation. Over time, managers affected by compassion fatigue may find themselves avoiding difficult discussions to avoid further emotional strain.
Case Study 1: The Cost of Avoiding Conflict
Sarah, a senior manager at a mid-sized tech company, oversees a team of software developers. One team member, Ben, consistently misses deadlines and submits code with frequent errors. Despite Sarah’s initial attempts to encourage Ben to improve, the issues continue. Instead of addressing the problem directly, Sarah starts to shoulder some of Ben’s work, hoping that he’ll notice and improve on his own.
This pattern goes on for months, and other team members begin to feel the effects. Frustrated with picking up Ben’s slack, they start to disengage. Productivity declines, and Sarah notices a general drop in morale. But Sarah feels stuck. She worries that if she confronts Ben, he’ll become defensive or demoralized, impacting the whole team.
Sarah’s reluctance is a classic example of the conflict-avoidance bias, where the brain prioritizes comfort over the perceived social “threat” of confrontation. Neuroscience research suggests that in situations of prolonged stress (like chronic underperformance), the brain’s default mode network often leads people to ruminate on negative outcomes without acting on solutions, worsening the situation.
The result is a vicious cycle where avoidance leads to worse performance and even more strained team dynamics. Over time, the mental burden increases for Sarah, who finds herself spending more time stressed over Ben’s performance than managing the team effectively.
Case Study 2: The Impact of Compassion Fatigue
Michael is a project manager at a healthcare non-profit. He has a strong desire to support his team, which often translates to giving underperforming employees second (and third) chances. For months, he tolerates underperformance from Carla, an administrator who frequently makes mistakes in filing critical documents. Michael feels that Carla is overwhelmed, so he avoids mentioning her mistakes, hoping that his patience will motivate her to improve.
However, instead of motivating Carla, Michael’s tolerance allows her to continue making errors, which start affecting the organization’s compliance and project timelines. Other team members start questioning Michael’s leadership, wondering why he lets Carla continue in the role without any correction.
This situation exemplifies compassion fatigue, a phenomenon where an individual’s empathy and patience are depleted over time, leading to a reduction in their ability to make objective decisions. In leadership, unchecked compassion fatigue can prevent a manager from taking necessary corrective action, allowing poor performance to go unaddressed.
Why Tolerating Poor Performance Backfires
Research in management psychology and neuroscience shows that avoiding performance issues can create a feedback loop of stress and underperformance. This impacts not only the manager but the entire team. Here are some key factors that explain why tolerating poor performance ultimately backfires:
Cognitive Dissonance: Managers often experience a disconnect between their belief in high standards and their tolerance of underperformance, leading to stress and dissatisfaction. The theory of cognitive dissonance, introduced by psychologist Leon Festinger, shows how holding conflicting beliefs or actions creates psychological discomfort that can lead to further avoidance rather than corrective action.
Social Loafing: When team members see one person not pulling their weight, they may reduce their own efforts, a phenomenon called social loafing. Social psychology research has shown that this effect is particularly strong in teams where poor performance goes unaddressed, creating a ripple effect of declining productivity.
Amygdala Hijack: In conflict situations, the amygdala may trigger a stress response that “hijacks” rational thinking, leading managers to avoid necessary conversations. Neuroscientist Daniel Goleman’s work on emotional intelligence emphasizes the importance of managing the amygdala’s response to maintain constructive behavior.
Negative Feedback Loop: Neuroscience also highlights how repeated avoidance creates a habit loop in the brain. Each time a manager avoids confrontation, the brain reinforces the association between avoidance and temporary relief, making it even harder to address performance issues in the future.
Strategies for Effectively Addressing Poor Performance
Moving beyond conflict avoidance and compassion fatigue requires managers to use strategies that balance empathy with accountability. Here are some research-backed techniques that help:
Reframe the Conversation: Instead of viewing performance feedback as confrontation, managers can view it as an opportunity to support growth. Neuroscience studies on reframing show that changing the perspective on difficult conversations helps reduce the amygdala’s stress response, enabling clearer thinking.
Use Clear, Measurable Goals: Setting specific, measurable goals helps clarify expectations, making it easier for both the manager and the employee to track performance and address issues objectively. According to Locke’s Goal-Setting Theory, clear goals significantly improve motivation and performance.
Adopt a Growth Mindset: A growth mindset, as developed by Carol Dweck, can be beneficial for both managers and employees. By framing feedback as a pathway to improvement, rather than punishment, managers create a more constructive, positive environment for addressing performance issues.
Encourage Self-Reflection: Before meeting with the employee, managers can reflect on their expectations and concerns. Techniques such as journaling or writing down specific issues help managers clarify their thoughts and reduce the amygdala’s influence on the conversation.
Utilise Regular Check-ins: Regular check-ins allow managers to address small issues before they become major problems. As Goleman notes, emotionally intelligent leaders use consistent, low-stakes conversations to keep performance on track, reducing the need for high-stakes confrontations.
"The essence of effective feedback is not confrontation, but rather a conversation aimed at growth and improvement" –
Daniel Goleman Tweet
Neuroplasticity + Breaking the Cycle
Tolerating poor performance doesn’t just impact the employee in question; it affects the whole team and can lead to a decline in overall morale, productivity, and job satisfaction. By understanding the psychological and neurological factors that contribute to conflict avoidance, managers can develop strategies to break this cycle and create a culture that balances compassion with accountability.
While these patterns can become habitual, neuroplasticity—the brain’s ability to reorganize itself by forming new neural connections—provides a way to break avoidance cycles. By consciously choosing new behaviors, such as implementing regular feedback sessions, managers can gradually train their brains to experience difficult conversations as opportunities for growth rather than threats. This process involves actively rewiring neural pathways away from avoidance and toward constructive engagement.
To leverage neuroplasticity, managers can practice the following:
Exposure Therapy: Gradually introducing more frequent and lower-stakes feedback conversations can help managers reduce their amygdala response, making each subsequent conversation easier and less intimidating.
Mindfulness Training: Mindfulness practices increase activity in the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain associated with executive function, helping managers stay calm and focused in the face of challenging conversations.
Self-Reinforcement Techniques: When managers successfully address a performance issue, self-reward (such as acknowledging their progress) reinforces positive behavior, strengthening neural pathways that promote constructive conflict resolution.
5 Key Takeaways
Address Issues Early: Tackling performance issues as soon as they appear reduces stress and prevents larger problems from developing.
Reframe Conflict as Growth: Viewing feedback as an opportunity for improvement reduces the brain’s stress response and fosters a more constructive conversation.
Use Clear, Measurable Goals: Setting concrete goals helps avoid misunderstandings and makes it easier to hold employees accountable.
Adopt Regular Check-Ins: Frequent, low-stakes conversations allow managers to keep performance on track without resorting to high-stakes confrontations.
Develop Self-Awareness: Managers who understand their conflict-avoidance tendencies and recognise their brain’s stress responses are better equipped to address poor performance effectively.
By addressing performance issues constructively and proactively, managers can improve both individual and team outcomes, creating a work environment where everyone is held to a high standard and empowered to grow.
“Neuroscience is the foundation for the approach we bring to every engagement. Partnering with our leaders to provide the insights that allow for improved decision making resulting in organisational resilience. Carolyn Grant
Interested in Learning More?
Book a briefing on psychological safety today. Mitigate your greatest risk and drive high performing, thriving teams.