Landmark 2025 Decision puts CEOs on Notice
with
The Accountability Tipping Point: What the Gibson Conviction Means for Directors and CEOs
In February 2025, a landmark decision sent a shockwave through boardrooms and C-suites across Australasia: former Port of Auckland CEO Tony Gibson was convicted under New Zealand’s Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 (HSWA) following the tragic 2020 death of Stevedore Pala’amo Kalati. The case serves not just as a legal precedent, but as a powerful wake-up call for directors and CEOs: when it comes to safety, strategic oversight is not enough.
THE CASE: Gibson’s Conviction and Its Context
In the early hours of 30 August 2020, Pala’amo Kalati was fatally crushed by a falling container during a lifting operation. This tragedy triggered an investigation by Maritime New Zealand, resulting in prosecutions against the Port of Auckland Ltd (POAL) and its CEO, Tony Gibson.
While POAL pleaded guilty and was fined $500,000, Gibson was convicted under section 48(1) of the HSWA, which applies where an officer’s failure in due diligence exposes a person to risk of death or serious injury. He was fined $130,000, with $60,000 in court costs.
Despite multiple safety initiatives, Judge Bonnar KC made it clear: good intentions are not a defence. Gibson failed in his duty to gain insight into “work as done”—the actual practices on the ground. The failure to understand and address critical risks was central to the case.
THE LESSONS: What Due Diligence Really Means
The Court outlined 12 principles redefining due diligence for officers. Key takeaways include:
- Case-by-Case Basis
Due diligence depends on the specific facts and context of each situation. - Applies to All Officers
Obligations apply equally, regardless of the organisation’s size, complexity, or structure. - Beyond Oversight
Senior roles require more than governance—they must ensure compliance across operations. - Separate from PCBU Duties
Officers are not expected to fulfil the PCBU’s operational duties directly. - Personal Knowledge Required
Officers must stay informed and cannot rely solely on others or assume systems are working without enquiry. - Monitor Delegates
Officers must ensure health and safety delegates are competent and closely monitored. - Understand Operations
Officers must understand the organisation’s activities, including frontline work, to identify risks. - Embed Effective Systems
Policies alone aren’t enough—systems must be well-designed, embedded, and effective. - Ensure Information Flows
Health and safety data must reliably reach officers and other leaders. - Actively Verify Compliance
Officers must interrogate, not just accept, health and safety reports or claims. - Ongoing Reviews
Regular audits and reviews are essential to test the effectiveness of safety systems and practices. - Exceed Industry Norms if Needed
Following industry standards isn’t enough if they fall short of legal obligations.
Leadrship Takeaways
This ruling moves the goalposts. Boards and executives can no longer rely on written reports and well-intentioned frameworks. Regulators demands curiosity, verification, and active engagement. But what does this look like in action?
Key Takeaways for Officers from the Case
Understand Real Work
Officers must grasp how work is actually done, not just how it’s intended to be done, to spot risks.Strong Systems Matter
Robust reporting and safety systems are essential, especially in large organisations.Hands-On Doesn’t Reduce Responsibility
Active involvement in health and safety raises, not lowers, the standard expected.Don’t Rely Solely on Worker Compliance
Known non-compliance requires supervision, hard controls, and technology—interim measures may also be necessary.Act Promptly on Improvements
Identified safety gaps must be addressed quickly and effectively.Clear Rules and Documentation
Safe work rules must be clear and well-documented, along with the rationale behind safety decisions.Training and Supervision Are Essential
Workers need proper training and ongoing supervision to stay safe.CEO Approval Not Always Required
In large organisations, only higher-risk changes may need CEO sign-off.PCBU Breaches Don’t Always Implicate Officers
Officers may fulfil their duty even if the PCBU breaches its own, depending on what the officer knew and could influence.CEOs Are Strategically and Operationally Accountable
CEOs are responsible for both health and safety strategy and ensuring systems work effectively at the frontline.
Health and safety isn’t just a compliance issue. It’s a strategic risk, a cultural barometer, and—as Gibson’s conviction shows—a personal legal liability.
Carolyn McSweeney-Grant, CEO People Plus Science Tweet
PSYCHOLOGICAL SAFETY, NEUROSCIENCE & DUE DILIGENCE: THE MISSING LINKS
The 2025 Index found that only 27% of employees believe their senior leaders understand the real risks in their day-to-day work. In large, hierarchical organisations, that figure drops to 19%.
This gap is more than operational—it’s neurological. Neuroscience shows that the human brain defaults to cognitive ease: we favour familiar, low-effort explanations. This bias can lead leaders to trust formal reporting channels without questioning what’s missing. As Judge Bonnar noted, relying on “those below you” without verifying facts is not diligence—it’s denial.
Worse still, leaders often misread psychological signals. In organisations where psychological safety is low, employees are 62% less likely to report risks or near misses. The Index also found that in teams with low psychological safety, there was a 31% increase in unreported critical incidents.
put it best: “A good leader and conscientious officer may have the best intentions in the world but may still breach that [due diligence] duty.” - Judge Bonnar KC
WHY IT MATTERS NOW MORE THAN EVER
The Gibson case shows that due diligence now includes neuro-leadership. Leaders must:
- Interrupt cognitive biases that lead to over-reliance on filtered reports.
- Design systems that invite frontline feedback and make speaking up psychologically safe.
- Engage in active inquiry, not passive receipt of information.
FROM STRATEGIC INTENT TO SYSTEMS THAT WORK
Directors and CEOs must shift from intent to implementation. It’s not enough to have health and safety policies. You must:
- Embed them.
- Audit them.
- Monitor effectiveness.
- Act when gaps emerge.
If those systems aren’t working, you are expected to know—and act.
FIVE ACTIONS EVERY CEO AND DIRECTOR MUST TAKE NOW
- Get to Know the ‘Work as Done’
Go to the floor, shadow teams, ask questions. Direct experience gives you the unfiltered insight that reports often miss. - Interrogate Your Systems
When was your H&S system last tested in practice—not just on paper? Create loops of continuous improvement, real-time data, and feedback. - Build Psychological Safety
People won’t speak up if they feel judged or ignored. Invest in a culture where risks and concerns are voiced early and often. - Monitor, Don’t Delegate and Forget
Delegating is necessary, but not sufficient. Regularly check in on the execution, not just the strategy. Ask: “Is this working as intended?” - Audit and Adapt
Due diligence is dynamic. Audit your knowledge, systems, training, and frontline experiences regularly. Adjust based on new insights and risks.
The conviction of Tony Gibson isn’t just a legal headline. It’s a signal. A CEO with good intentions and multiple initiatives was still found legally responsible for a fatal workplace failure.
Don’t wait for tragedy—or prosecution—to ask whether your organisation’s safety systems are actually working. Due diligence isn’t about checking boxes. It’s about actively shaping a culture of safety, accountability, and trust.
The good news? You have the power to transform oversight into insight, intention into impact, and responsibility into results.
Start today.
“Neuroscience is the foundation for the approach we bring to every engagement. Partnering with our leaders to provide the insights that allow for improved decision making resulting in organisational resilience. Carolyn Grant
Interested in Learning More?
Book a briefing on psycho-social assessments and organisational resilience today. Mitigate your greatest risk and drive high performing, thriving teams.